Social Sciences: (First year grad student)
VG/G, G/F, E/E (Nothing)
Improvement over my undergrad application for sure and generally very positive.
Reviewer 3 actually said I, "was a solid candidate for the graduate research grant".
Most of my critique from Reviewer 1 was to publish and present at more professional conferences (0 pubs and 1 professional conference presentation - my field is slow). But they still said that I was competitive. Reviewer 2 had all critique on my research area, a few small questions and the general include more "discussion of more theoretical and practical implications".
Sucks to have not won but my advisor was happy with the comments despite not winning and we are potentially discussing things to improve on for next year. I'm a first year graduate student and from my understanding I can apply again.