I am fortunate to be choosing between UMD and UMass PhD offers. My area is AI/ML. While other factors, such as (especially) research/advisor match, (and to a lesser extent) local area, stipend amount, etc. will likely be the deciding factors in my decision, I do not want to entirely ignore rank/reputation (for example, all else being equal, rank/reputation could be a tie-breaker) and was wondering about how people felt about the rank, reputation, and overall relative quality of the two programs. Here are my thoughts/observations so far:
UMD is ranked higher overall in CS, but UMass has a better AI rank.
Contradicting #1 to some extent, I have had two professors at my current institution outright tell me that UMass is the better overall program.
My thoughts (at least prior to talking to those professors) was that the ranking difference was probably fairly insignificant. There is a similar 6-year old thread here that mostly agrees with this thought, but it is a bit dated and things could have changed.
What do you all think? Are the professors I talked to right about UMass being significantly better? Are the posts in that old thread more correct about the two being about the same? Do you all have any other thoughts or advice about the two programs? Thank you!