Jump to content

Let's Take a Poll - Most and Least Responsive Programs


aba1984

Recommended Posts

Since we're sitting around waiting.......................

 

There's some programs that don't reply, no matter what, yet there's some that are answering every question you have.

I wanna know: Which program were you most disappointed in and which went above and beyond to answer your questions?

 

Best ______________

Worst _____________

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've had good experiences emailing Boston U, UConn, and Johns Hopkins. Harvard has a good system set up to check on GRE scores. Yale was a nightmare trying to get in touch with graduate admissions.

 

I only reached out to check on GRE scores, so it might've been different if I was contacting about other information.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I emailed NYU (Sackler) early in the season (like september or october I think) and they took 3 weeks to answer my question. 

 

Edit: I just double checked. They actually took a month and 3 days to respond.

Edited by perfectionist
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a very small sample size but:

Best: UCSD or UC-Berkeley (emailed them about my missing GRE scores and it was fixed within the hour)

Worst: Wisconsin (Emailed three different people about the same missing GRE scores, didn't hear back for a week, had to call them and they didn't have them at all, they were the only school that didn't have them, so I'm thinking it was an error on there part)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best:  Sloan Kettering replied to me next day every time I emailed them, so I think they're pretty great.

Worst:  I had no need to contact anyone else, so I guess I can't really say much here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best: WashU replied the next day to my emails even after applications were due

Worst: Vanderbilt stil hasn't replied to me, its been over 3 weeks. Guess I know what that means.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best: University of Iowa. Not only did they answer my question, they followed up a few weeks later to check the applicaiton process was going smoothly.

Worst: Tied. University X lost my application fee (found it later) but were super helpful (and funny) via Twitter; University Y gave me conflicting information and frequently misspelled my name.

 

Poll: We always worry when we misspell a professor's name or make a typo. Do you hold it against a univerity if their communication is poorly written and riddled with errors? I will admit I have been biased against programs when receiving such e-mails.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great experiences with all except UMich and Ga Tech .

I have confirmation from my school that transcript was mailed a month before deadline to Mich. As of dec 24 still not showing as received. I have my school send a Etranscript which was picked up by Mich that morning. Took another 10 days and multiple unanswered emails to show as received.

Didn't apply to GaTech as they would not respond to my question about when recommendation letters were due; sent me on the endless loop of referring me to one place, they refer me back, phone number given disconnected etc... I gave up. Website very unclear.

On the whole, I thought the majority were responsive and organized.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Best: Haven't had too much back-and-forth problems, but almost all of the universities this year have been pretty awesome.

 

Worst: UCLA.  I applied last application cycle, didn't get my rejection notice until August.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Better: I thought Vandy was pretty helpful since (the people who are responsible for the corresponding graduate program) replies my e-mail very quickly. I was applying to 2 programs at Vandy and I got to communicate with them closely. That's also true for Purdue, where they make me a recommendation to apply another program for better fit (although I didn't not and eventually was rejected).

 

I applied to a lot of schools for Fall 2012, and I find it difficult to pick which ones are the best, but I do remember the worst:

 

Yale -- I was actually trying to switch program (from BBS) after submission due to a POI recommendation, but they replied my e-mail response late (weeks). The BBS people are OK, graduate admission are the worst. Hardly provide any meaningful response. I, at some point, was suspecting that the person who replied my e-mail was a cynical undergrad.

 

Columbia -- Sofa king slow response (~ 2 months). Actually, they wouldn't send me a rejection letter until June, after I inquired about my application status (given that I knew the interview weekend(s) dates).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best:  Washington University in St. Louis- they even respond during the Sunday night that applications are due; University of Iowa- quick responses and usually answer questions

Worst:  Biology@Princeton- No word from them or email  :(  Stanford Genetic Department- No emails, and never answer phone calls

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Aberrant, do you remember the names of the people at Vanderbilt you send your emails to? I sent my emails to the IGP director and administrator, but maybe there is someone else I should be emailing?

 

For IGP, I would suggest you to contact the program coordinator (IGP Program Coordinator) instead of the director / admin. Typically, director / admin don't response to e-mail from applicants.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best: Yale (super super nice on the phone+emails), Cold Spring Harbor (very nice and all, but I didn't contact them before I got an interview, so I don't know how they were before they sent out the interview), Davis (responded in less than an hour every time I contacted them (I had various problems with my application). I was really impressed)

 

Worst: MIT (didn't reply to any of my emails, didn't pick up the phone and I really hated their application website)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...

Worst: UCLA by far. The other 6 were all roughly equal in responsiveness, but UCLA sent me all of these generic emails about my status, and when I inquired as to whether they were missing something in my application--nothing. Yet they kept sending me emails that indicated something wasn't done with my application. I checked everything I sent them and determined everything should've been in on my end, but I have no idea what has happened with that application.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best: U Penn Biomedical Sciences by far. They answered me very quickly, and they are the only school where all the POIs I contacted actually responded back to me. Unfortunately, I screwed up the application :(

 

Worst: Stony Brook MGM. They took forever to get back to me with an interview and I had to reach out to them several times for the same question. On top of that, they never spoke to me after my interview until I called (at the end of March) and they told me I was waitlisted. I know they email you about rejections, because I know people who were rejected.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best: UGA--extremely communicative with no fake out subject lines. Fast turn around on application. Fast itinerary schedule for visit. Easy to reach by phone or email.

Almost tied for best: UNC--also communicative and easy to reach but didn't provide updates like UGA does on their own accord.

Worst: Duke. Radio silence the whole time. I feel like it's a take my money and don't give a crap. Doesn't bother notify rejections until all acceptances are taken even for people not selected for interviews.

Ga Tech has been pretty silent too except the POI and one email confirming they got all my stuff. Impossible to reach grad office by phone, grad office turn around on emails is almost a week.

Emory was really good too but not above and beyond good. I do appreciate the immediate notification after interviews scheduled that I was waitlisted then fast notification everyone accepted interviews and I was rejected.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Most responsive: University of Iowa/CU Denver

Worst: University of Washington

 

Here are some better explanations:

 

Iowa- this was the first school that contacted me for an interview. They do rolling admissions, with a preferred deadline of Dec 5 and an actual deadline of Jan 1. I heard back on Dec 9 at ~7pm Iowa-time. I accepted the offer the next day and was replied to in less than 20 minutes. The coordinator is one of the friendliest program coordinators I've spoken to. She's very accommodating and understanding, and she always responded to my emails within a couple hours.

 

CU Denver- their application is a little different than most, so I had a few questions along the way. Also a very responsive, friendly, accommodating coordinator -- response times within an hour. Interview invite and acceptance were both via phone with follow-up email. I think of the phone calls as counting toward "responsiveness" because they feel more personal, like I haven't been reduced to a set of stats.

 

University of Washington- Responsive? I guess, sorta. Actually read my emails? Dubious. When I was invited to interview (via email), two dates were offered: Feb 2-5 or Feb 3-6 (yeah, talk about "alternate" dates). I emailed back to explain that I had committed to an interview and had a Feb 5 conflict, and I asked if there were any other dates available to interview. The response I got back was "Great! You'll be in the Feb 2-5 group" (that was the ENTIRE email response). So I wrote back and restated that I had a Feb 5 conflict. This time, I was told that I could leave the morning of the 4th. I thought I was in the clear.

A few days passed, and I was given instructions (mass email) to find a flight time and book it. I found a flight that left the morning of the 4th and sent an email to the coordinator, reminding her that I was leaving the morning of the 4th. She responded with, "You can't leave on the 4th, you'll miss half of the interview." At that point, I formally emailed her to decline the interview.    

Edited by pasteltomato
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use