Jump to content

PhD applications poll

anthroflea

By anthroflea
in Anthropology Forum

 Share

Admission to PhD  

44 members have voted

  1. 1. Were you admitted to an anthropology PhD Program with or without an M.A.?

    • 1.1 Did you get in with a B.A.?
      8
    • Yes, with less than a year field experience and at least one publication.
      2
    • Yes, with at least a year of field experience but no publications.
      10
    • Yes, with at least a year of field experience, at least one publication.
      5
    • Yes, other (please elaborate in discussion thread).
      6
    • 1.2 Did you get in with a B.A. with post-bacc classes?
      0
    • Yes, with less than a year field experience and at least one publication.
      2
    • Yes, with at least a year of field experience but no publications.
      0
    • Yes, with at least a year of field experience, at least one publication.
      0
    • Yes, other (please elaborate in discussion thread).
      0
    • 1.3 Did you get in with an M.A.?
      7
    • M.A. with less than a year field experience and at least one publication.
      5
    • M.A. with at least a year of field experience but no publications.
      6
    • M.A. with at least a year of field experience, at least one publication.
      2
    • M.A. with other (please elaborate in discussion thread).
      2

  2. 2. At the schools you got in, did you contact your POI prior to applying?

    • Yes, at all schools I got into.
      26
    • No, at no schools.
      3
    • Yes, at most schools I got into.
      9
    • Yes, but not at any schools I got into.
      2
    • Yes, at the one school I applied and got into.
      1
    • I didn't talk to my POI about my application, but he/she works at my BA/MA institution.
      0
    • I didn't talk to my POI about my application, but have worked with that person before.
      2

  3. 3. Did you visit the university you got into prior to applying? (Multiple answers possible)

    • Yes, I got into most univiersities I visited.
      8
    • No, first time I visited was after admission.
      24
    • I got into some schools I didn't visit but they are in the minority.
      3
    • I don't think visiting the department made a difference in the outcome.
      6
    • I visited my top choice and got in.
      4
    • I feel like it was a mistake to not visit my top choice.
      1
    • I don't have and tangible evidence but feel like the visit gave me an advantage.
      4
    • I don't have any tangible evidence but don't feel like the visit gave me an advantage.
      3

Recommended Posts

anthroflea Espresso Shot

anthroflea

Posted
Posted (edited)

I decided to steal this idea from other fields ;)

 

[Note: I've edited the options in question 1. Unfortunately that means that the answers of whoever voted before the change no longer reflect what they chose. I can't do anything to change that -- so please keep that in mind when looking at the results! --fuzzy]

Edited by anthroflea
Question 1 edited to add sub-questions.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Kaitri Double Shot

Kaitri

Posted
Posted

Some suggestions:

 

1) Ask about background (i.e. had teaching or research experience).

 

2) Split the last question into two - a yes/no question (radio buttons, select one response only) and then a series of select all that apply questions for miscellaneous items such as perceived inpact of the visit.

 

3) I would also suggest asking questions about POI input/interviews.

 

4) Add a section for "other" to the first question. Some people may get offers despite having very different educational or professional backgrounds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Kaitri Double Shot

Kaitri

Posted
Posted

Yeah - that's not as relevant.

 

The person who is managing the philosophy thread is changing it to a surveymonkey link instead of doing a poll through the forum software, which might work better here. Normally I would just offer to write the questionnaire (since survey research is literally my job), but I don't know that much about the U.S. PhD application process.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
anthroflea Espresso Shot

anthroflea

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Ok, I took some of your suggestions, but couldn't take all. The things the pole template lets me do are relatively limited and I cannot ask more than 3 questions. I left out research experience, because I feel like field experience and publications are, in most cases, the same thing. (I realize that this is not always the case, but unfortunately, as I said, the pole is relatively limited). I also didn't ask about research experience for the M.A. because I assume most people in an M.A. have at least a tiny bit of teaching experience and those who don't can mention it in the discussion thread. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
sarab Macchiato

sarab

Posted
Posted

I got in with a B.A and without publications, but my Honors Thesis is pending publication in the university journal. I know that doesn't really matter anyway, so I didn't mention it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
daykid Latte

daykid

Posted
Posted

so since the questions got changed my answers are no longer correctly represented:

 

Got in with a BA

Over 1 year of field work

No Publications

Contacted POIs at all universities I applied to

Didn't visit until after I was accepted

Link to comment
Share on other sites
anthroflea Espresso Shot

anthroflea

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I'm so sorry daykid. I didn't know changing the poll would change the answers. So I think we should just leave the poll as is from now on. My answers are also wrong now:(

 

I think there were only about 4(??) people who had taken the poll before it was changed. So hopefully it won't skew the results too much. Hopefully we'll get a lot of people taking this. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
NoSleepTilBreuckelen Latte

NoSleepTilBreuckelen

Posted
Posted (edited)

Sorry to ask another question, but does 1-year field experience mean 1 continuous year of fieldwork? What about something like 2 or 3 summers of field-work and some other fieldwork projects between 1 - 4 weeks in length (archaeology subfield)…. Would that be less than a year? I just ask because other than working CRM for an extended period of time, a lot of archaeology applicants (myself included) might have a bit of a piecemeal record, with multiple projects, but that time-wise it would take quite a few of these experiences to add up to a year.

 

Thanks for setting up this poll, btw!  :)

Edited by NoSleepTilBreuckelen
Link to comment
Share on other sites
anthroflea Espresso Shot

anthroflea

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Good point NoSleep. I guess the one year is a bit arbitrary and maybe not the best category choice. This was really not an easy poll to create  :unsure:  I know a lot of people who worked in CRM for like 5 years before applying to the PhD and the question was meant to differientiate those from the people who "only" have a 2 week field school. Similarly, I know somebody who spent a year in Africa doing cultural research versus a lot of people who did a summer field school in cultural. I assume that everyone has at least some experience before applying to PhDs. I don't want to change the poll now because that'll change verybody's answers, but I can see how this is an ambiguous category. (Especially when it comes to research for honors/MA theses). 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mutualist007 Latte

mutualist007

Posted
Posted

Maybe it would be a good idea to do a poll that compares the attributes of those who got it to the attributes of those who did not get in right away (who are waitlisted or rejected). Any takers for creating that kind of poll? If no one does this in the next week I may do it, or I may get fancy and create a larger survey.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
DigDeep(inactive) Mocha

DigDeep(inactive)

Posted
Posted

Maybe it would be a good idea to do a poll that compares the attributes of those who got it to the attributes of those who did not get in right away (who are waitlisted or rejected). Any takers for creating that kind of poll? If no one does this in the next week I may do it, or I may get fancy and create a larger survey.

 

Here's a link to some info sarab and I worked up! It's only focused on accepted students, however. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mutualist007 Latte

mutualist007

Posted
Posted

Here's a link to some info sarab and I worked up! It's only focused on accepted students, however. 

 

Looks cool. I still think it would be informative to compare the attributes of accepted vs not accepted :)

 

Maybe some demographic information and some other qualitative stuff like time spent outside the classroom in experiential activities would be good too.

 

But I'm impressed with what you have. It shows what one can expect among the accepted crowd.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 5 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

  I accept