I had a very similar experience with Alfred sculpture... I believe I was their first interview on Tuesday. I had prepared but was a little uneasy for some reason and then when I got to the interview my nerves really got to me. My only other interview has been with UO, it was a totally different format (only two professor, over the phone, and pretty quick and informal). I had felt I came across maybe a little too formal and overly-confident with UO, but with Alfred I felt very unclear and lacking confidence. So not to worry... at least once other had a weird Alfred interview.
As for other schools I'm assuming I'm out of the running for UCI and UT Austin. The only other dangling out there is VCU sculpture. I've been applying away for other opportunities assuming I might need another year to get what I want. This has been my first time around and I've really learned so much