From the looks of it, the biggest factor in your decision is money - that is, since you did not mention any other pieces of interest from either school. If that is true, then go with the better school from a financial standpoint.
Something else I will throw out there, I say you reject going to Syracuse since they just rejected me for their MLIS program (grrrr). Hajk, but I think you need to put together something to look further into what you will get from each school. For myself, I put together an excel sheet with pros and cons for a variety of factors in order to compare the schools I am deciding between, it seems to make the decision much easier to understand - although I have not made it...
Hopefully something I said helps, good luck!