Warelin
-
Posts
1,453 -
Joined
-
Days Won
46
Posts posted by Warelin
-
-
46 minutes ago, grace2137 said:
question.. would a program email you if they were missing a rec letter and the deadline passed?
Unfortunately, this depends on the program and may depend on policies set by either the program or the Graduate School. There are several that I'm aware of that would e-mail you about missing materials. Others only update via their portal and won't notify if materials are missing. I imagine most would be happy to answer any questions if you're concerned about missing materials though. Additional delays may or may not occur if it has to be processed by the Graduate School prior to being forwarded to the department or Admissions Committee.
-
-
The following might help!
-
5 minutes ago, grace2137 said:
on a somewhat related note- how might a POI being on leave this school year (2019-20) affect things? Presumably one could still work with them after they return, but would adcoms not want to take students interested in working w them without being able to confer with them etc?
I don't think a POI being on leave this school year would make any difference. In Literature, you're admitted to the department rather than to work as a member of a certain faculty's lab. As such, the admissions committee makes decisions on behalf of the department. Most members of the department will not be on the admissions committee. In most cases, you wouldn't select who you're interested in serving on your committee until after the second semester of your second year. As such, I wouldn't worry about it as long as they've recently as the faculty member has taught grad-level courses. There are some faculty members which often have never taught at the grad-school level and might not be available to serve as your dissertation chair.
-
21 hours ago, grace2137 said:
I’m in a very similar position with one of my Jan deadline schools!! in part because my research interests have become more solidified and also because one of the faculty members I was interested in working with moved to another program. I’m also torn between apprehension about the app fee but being hung up on the fact that profs already submitted recs.
Professors understand that interests change and wouldn't hold it against you if you decided against a school. The application process is ultimately about your future and interests. Professors also won't know if you decided to not apply to a school unless they're on the committee for that school. Those records are kept confidential. I think applying to schools which you feel are your preferred schools is the most important thing you can do. Your preferences might change again during grad school; schools know that. If you think there are schools with a better fit that fit your interests, apply to those instead. Is it possible to submit an application to the university where the professor you were interested in moved to? Does that school interest you?
-
3 hours ago, grace2137 said:
On that note... is there a thread somewhere with a list of the notification dates from previous cycles? I swear I’ve seen one but I haven’t been able to search it up.
-
17 hours ago, Narrative Nancy said:
I was wavering on whether to apply to a Jan 1 school and I'm sure part of me is doing it to delay the anxiety that comes with the waiting phase
For what it's worth, Washington University in St. Louis has a January deadline but has traditionally been on the first schools to accept students. In some cases, applying to different places might mean less waiting as long as you're interested in all schools you're applying to.
WashU, Emory, Notre Dame and Duke have also traditionally paid for flights and accommodations for accepted and/or final round candidates.
-
5 hours ago, alittlebitofthat said:
If I'm reapplying to a place where I was waitlisted last year, is it a good idea to mention the waitlist situation in my SOP?
I'm not sure if it would be beneficial to mention waitlists from previous years. I think the admissions committee changes each year and each one will look for different things to fill in a cohort. I also think there are far more valuable things you can talk about in such a small word count.
-
33 minutes ago, tiredderridean said:
oh no, they didn't do it the last cycle! i remember emailing them to check.
That's good to hear then. There were reports that they did from users on this board. It caused some panic last year.
-
42 minutes ago, tiredderridean said:
To clarify, it’s only Duke Literature that does interviews (and there tends to be two rounds, the second being part of their campus visit). Duke English doesn’t have the habit of interviewing, I think?
Historically, Duke Literature is the only of the two that does interviews. Last cycle, Duke English was reported to do interviews.
-
2 hours ago, CaliAcademic said:
Naive question: Do most English/humanities PhD programs conduct interviews after the application deadline(s)? I've been under the impression that the writing sample is in lieu of an in-person interview. Can someone help clarify? Thanks!
Chicago recently started interviewing a few cycles ago. In the past, they've extended interview offers to more people than they had "slots" for. At least one person has claimed they've been extended an offer without an interview.
Emory, Notre Dame, and Duke also do interviews. I think somebody mentioned that Northeastern started doing in-person interviews last year.
-
49 minutes ago, politics 'n prose said:
at least Penn State straight up tells you that the PhD program wants nothing to do with students who don't already have an MA.
Penn State's structure is that the majority of its graduates apply to the MA program. Most of the graduates from their MA program then continue onto their PHD program. As a result, they only accept 1-2 people with an external MA into their PHD program which is determined by how many people leave after the MA.
-
2 hours ago, onerepublic96 said:
Desperately trying to polish 6 applications due on the 15th as we speak.
You can do it!
-
24 minutes ago, The_Alchemist said:
I assume that there is a restriction on editing functions for new members such as myself.
There is no ability to edit (after 60 minutes) for members because what happened (in the past) was that members would create posts, get answers, then edit out their posts. This often resulted in future individuals not understanding the context of said posts.
-
-
Hello!
We are interested in recruiting new moderators and area moderators to join our staff. Moderators help their fellow members by answering questions and keeping the forum free from spam.
Moderators and Area Mods are an all-volunteer team.
Description:
Moderators would handle general moderating, possibly results, forum direction, forum admin/approvals/spam)
Area Mods would handle a niche of forums, spam cleanup, and enforcement of policies.Additional responsibilities of both include answering questions from the community,
Requirements:- Active participation
- The ability to work well within a team
- Respect for all users
If you are interested, simply send me a PM with the information below.
Essential information when applying:
- Let us know your availability
- Which forums are you most interested in moderating?
- Explain your experience as a moderator (if applicable)
- Why do you want to become a moderator?
Your applications will be reviewed; if selected, either @TGCA or I will contact you.
I look forward to receiving and reviewing your application! -
14 minutes ago, karamazov said:
Yep. From Laney Graduate School Admissions:
"Thank you for submitting your application to the Laney Graduate School at Emory University.
The program you applied to has access to your application, and will let you know the results of their review in due course."
Did you get anything more than that?
I even checked my bank account to make sure I hadn't, like, paid the fee in my sleep or something, but nothing has been deducted from Emory. And my application portal says I've submitted my application.
Did you participate in any of the following programs: http://gs.emory.edu/admissions/waiver-qualified.html
Alternatively, some schools may offer an automatic fee waiver to graduates from certain schools. -
On 12/2/2019 at 3:07 PM, Indecisive Poet said:
FYI, I emailed the guy who sent the "we've received everything" email about this and he said that the online application system takes a long time to update but that he's very on top of things, so if he's emailed to say he has everything, then he has everything.
Sarah at Washington University in St. Louis and Nathan at Northwestern are really excellent in their organization and answering questions.
-
2 hours ago, CanadianEnglish said:
But real talk, what am I supposed to do now? Refresh my email every 15 seconds until mid-March? Work on my thesis? Be a productive citizen? It all sounds terrible.
Apply to hidden gems that you overlooked the first time? Find real hidden gems outside?
-
10 minutes ago, indoorfireworks said:
I’ve submitted all four that are due today but I’m still waiting on a letter of rec. The prof says she is working on it and will have it turned in today but good lord being this close to the wire makes me anxious.
For what it's worth, one of my professors submitted ~2 weeks late on an application that said letters were due on the same day. I was still accepted by that school.
-
14 hours ago, The Hoosier Oxonian said:
OK, here's a new question. For schools that optionally let you list other places you're applying, is it better to do it or not? (Some, it seems, don't make it optional.) I can't figure out what the purpose of this is and whether it could potentially help or hurt one's chances to let a top school know you're applying to a lower-ranked one or vice versa. Thoughts?
I think schools are just curious to see who they end up losing students to if they're accepted elsewhere. Is stipend playing a major factor? Are other programs introducing new certificates or initiatives that's causing an impact on decisions? I don't think schools have the resources to keep track of every school so this allows them to identify trends and use the data in however they see best fit.
-
On 4/19/2019 at 2:22 PM, sgaw10 said:
Is there any chance I could get by in St. Louis without a car? Coming from Chicago, I prefer not to own a car. But I realize public transit down there isn't so great.
Depending on where you live, it could be very easy to live and get by without a car. There are a lot of transportation options near Washington University in St. Louis, Saint Louis University, University of Missouri - St. Louis and Webster University. Options around Downtown are also plentiful. Transportation options become harder when you move toward the suburbs which are more than 20 miles away from St. Louis city. However, St. Louis is affordable and has a wide variety of neighborhoods available depending on your preferences.
-
On 11/25/2019 at 2:28 PM, Glasperlenspieler said:
In most PhD programs, anything less than an A- is a very bad sign and is being given as a sort of warning. Even if there aren't explicit GPA requirements, there are GPA requirements.
I think it’s important to note that sometimes a misunderstanding on what a professor expects might also lead to a lower than expected grade. Sometimes, a class might not have anything graded until the very end of the semester. A class or two below an A- might be overlooked but consistently falling below a 3.5 might signal that grad school might not be right for that person.
-
1 hour ago, w@term3lon said:
I am wondering: If 3 out of 4 of my letters are submitted, will my application be considered incomplete? Even though I have met the minimum # of 3 letters?
Your application would not be considered incomplete.
2020 Applicants
in Literature, and Rhetoric and Composition
Posted
Here's to good news!
Congrats on being done.
Over the years, people have been surprised by being accepted at places, being rejected by places and rejecting offers that they thought they'd accept. The atmosphere on the other side is very different when it comes to choosing when people are presented with multiple choices.