Jump to content

Noegenesis

Members
  • Posts

    107
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Adelaide9216 in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    Simply do a search for social work faculty positions and compare them to other disciplines to get an idea. I just checked and there are indeed some tenure-track openings but not like a ton.
  2. Downvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Statboy in Lack of Statistics Classes/Research   
    If you are equally qualified as another similar applicant, the applicant with more statistics courses will be considered more favorably than you. There are plenty of statistics courses online. Is there any way you can strengthen your application?
  3. Downvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from bayessays in Lack of Statistics Classes/Research   
    If you are equally qualified as another similar applicant, the applicant with more statistics courses will be considered more favorably than you. There are plenty of statistics courses online. Is there any way you can strengthen your application?
  4. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from thelifeinpink in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    Wow, you really killed it this season! Congratulations!!
  5. Like
    Noegenesis got a reaction from doctormelody in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    Wow, you really killed it this season! Congratulations!!
  6. Upvote
    Noegenesis reacted to Teaching Faculty Wannabe in Stipends and Taxes   
    Hi there! Taxes are not typically withheld from fellowships, but are usually withheld from stipends for TA and RA positions. I only know this from doing tons of research. I have included a lot previous forums about this subject. I am sorry it is a lot, but taxes are super complicated and I am still trying to figure them out myself. I hope this helps!
     
  7. Upvote
    Noegenesis reacted to jeffster in Advice for a first year PhD student   
    Sigaba, I'm afraid I can't tell if you're just trolling, or if you're really this unfamiliar with how internet forums work. The effectiveness of a forum is undermined when no one posts; it is not undermined by people posting similar questions. I'm pretty new here, but I don't think most of us view this as a information repository so much as we view it as a discussion community. There are a lot of reasons that users should post new threads, which TakeruK outlined quite thoroughly above. In fact, a perfectly valid reply from you would have said "Hey, you can also check out these past threads on this topic. Good luck!" That would have been something a helpful member of a forum community would do. Unfortunately you chose to share some links then couple it with a rant equating poor (in your mind) internet forum behavior to grad school research habits.

    And just to avoid contributing even further to the hijacking of this thread, I'll add for the OP that I don't think you should give your dog away. There's another thread around here somewhere about pets in grad school - plenty of people manage it!
  8. Downvote
    Noegenesis reacted to Sigaba in Advice for a first year PhD student   
    Do what you can to minimize the temptation to reinvent the wheel.
    Do your level best to learn from those who have gone before you and have asked similar questions.
    Consider the utility of incorporating your questions into ongoing discussions.
    When assessing the guidance you've received, consider the background, the expertise and the experience of the person who offered it.







    If I sound snarky it is because this BB is going through a phase in which newer members are repeating questions that have been addressed many, many times. While this trend provides opportunities to get great guidance from experienced graduate students such as jullietmercredi, it also provides opportunities to miss equally sound guidance from experienced graduate students such as jullietmercredi.

    IMO, this trend represents a "lost opportunity" for many of you to start the transition from being undergraduates to being graduate students. As graduate students, you will often encounter an implicit expectation that you are doing the leg work to find the answers to your own questions, and from there generating additional questions and answers. (In some quarters, this leg work is called "research".)

    Additionally, some of you who are in your twenties may be walking into a buzzsaw as new graduate students. Your cohort is developing a reputation for having attitudes of entitlement and self-absorption. (Consider how members of the generation of 1965 talk about the OWS and Tea Party movements) Regardless of the accuracy of this perception (Christopher Lasch had the same complaints back in 1978), perception is reality.

    While it is your choice as to what questions you want to ask and how you want to ask them, do not be surprised if those who are most capable of helping you decide to tune you out. If you think this can't happen to you, ask yourself why you're asking strangers on the internet for guidance rather than going into a professor's office and getting mentored?

    My $0.02.
  9. Downvote
    Noegenesis reacted to Sigaba in Advice for a first year PhD student   
    @Jeffster--

    My conclusion is based upon using the search function for less than a minute and finding several threads that answer the questions asked in the OP. That is, in less time than it took the OP to type up the questions, the member could have found previously offered guidance.

    I understand that many newer members of this BB would like to think that the challenges they face are new, that their questions are unique, and that their insights are novel. This attitude undermines the effectiveness of the BB because it encourages newer members to start new threads rather than to build upon existing ones.

    In regards to your characterization of my "hijacking" the thread, you have again demonstrated an inability to read carefully. The OP specifically asked for "age related' advice which my reply offered.
  10. Like
    Noegenesis got a reaction from miffle in Advice on Pre-PhD Masters (Psychology)?   
    A master's will certainly help your application. I would just add that there are tons of resources for learning statistics/data analysis online (Coursera, EdX, Datacamp, etc.), but you cannot gain research experience online. Thus, finding a graduate degree that would add to your CVs "research experiences" and tie to your PhD research interests should be your foremost priority. Hope this helps!
  11. Upvote
    Noegenesis reacted to fortsibut in Is it possible that an admitted student recommend his/her partner/fiance?   
    That was a real cheap shot.  =/
  12. Downvote
    Noegenesis reacted to Sigaba in Is it possible that an admitted student recommend his/her partner/fiance?   
    "Terrible advice" because it worked for you once at one institution. And since then how successful has your approach to applying to graduate school been?
  13. Upvote
    Noegenesis reacted to Bso415 in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    Sorry, I didn't proof read or clarify  my fault! What I meant was... he emailed back apologizing for writing "joint msw/phd". That was a typo. I was accepted to just* the PhD program- no msw. Then he attached the formal acceptance letter where everything is accurate. No msw classes... and if I'm lucky, I will be able to petition out of a few PhD courses because of my DSW course work. Boom. 
  14. Downvote
    Noegenesis reacted to Derriduh in Interviews/Acceptances/Rejections Fall 2019   
    Oh boy. I'll assume based on your tortured writing that you were not a celebratory admit.
  15. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Teaching Faculty Wannabe in Self-care Tips/Advice   
    That's a powerful trait. Not many people enjoy or excel at the interview process. Hope things work out for you this time.
  16. Like
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Number4 in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    Hello! There is already a thread here:
    Best of luck with your applications!
  17. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from masters_gmat in Data Science elite schools : what are my chances   
    Your chances seem pretty solid. But why have you restricted yourself to "elite" schools? Is there a significant difference in the education you'll receive?
  18. Like
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Adelaide9216 in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    That's awesome! Just gotta get that diss done before year 4 then, otherwise you'll need extra funding.
  19. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from LopeyTall in I made it past the first round and I am now a Fulbright semi-finalist — should I tell the graduate programs I applied to?   
    I wouldn't contact the graduate programs. Your LORs should already attest that you are "of a high caliber" and a one-line addition to your resume would probably not affect your chances significantly anyway.
  20. Like
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Shabsherv in Statement of Purpose   
    Throw away the first sentence, which is cliche. And you should refrain from using negative reasons such as "not that professional in research" as your motivation for applying to a MA program.
  21. Like
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Adelaide9216 in How often do students fail? (master's thesis)   
    This probably answers your own question. If you want a more definitive answer, your best bet is still your advisor (a face to face meeting should give you some clues), other professors at your department, especially those who have supervised master's theses in the past, and your institution's guidelines for writing a master's thesis (either a general guideline not restricted to a specific department or requirements from similar disciplines, e.g., psychology, sociology).
  22. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from AtTJP in Spring admissions: how eccentric is that?   
    I've never applied for Spring admissions, and schools will definitely vary in their policies. Your best bet is to talk to the schools that you are interested in and ask them specifically about the admissions process during Spring. Good luck!
  23. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from AtTJP in Spring admissions: how eccentric is that?   
    If the chances are so low, there certainly is more incentive to apply for Fall admissions, because the application process involves a lot of time and commitment, on your part and your recommenders, and having to go through this process twice, in the event that you fail the first time, is probably not the best use of your time. However, if you feel that you are the cream of the crop, in terms of your research experiences, publication record, and academic record, then sure, give it a shot.
  24. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Adelaide9216 in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    Congratulations!!! ?
  25. Upvote
    Noegenesis got a reaction from Adelaide9216 in Fall 2019 Phd Social Work /Welfare   
    Almost there, good luck!
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use