Jump to content

margarets

Members
  • Posts

    131
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from Ambigiousbuthopeful in Is this over-confidence?   
    And I think you should back off. You didn't read the theses, you don't know the program or even the university. Or me, for that matter.

    "impart" "wisdom"

    Please.
  2. Upvote
    margarets got a reaction from Cookie in Is this over-confidence?   
    As part of my due diligence for the program I've got my eye on for 2013, I've looked at some of the theses of past grads from the program.

    And they were....OK.

    I didn't look at them all, just ones that interested me or appeared to have something in common with my thesis topic. Of course I have no idea if I was looking at the best or worst ones, though the sample was pretty random, so it should have been a mix.

    Anyway, like I said, they were OK. I wasn't blown away by the brilliance of any of them and in some cases I was definitely unimpressed. No disrespect re: the time and effort it took to do them though.

    I've shifted my thinking from "I can probably do this" to "I can TOTALLY do this". It will be a lot of work but well within my intellectual capabilities.

    I don't know... perhaps my idea of what graduate work is all about was too high? Like only the super-smarties can do it and their work is always staggeringly original?

    Maybe all you need is a good brain, a decent idea and a fair chunk of self-discipline?
  3. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from Cookie in Is this over-confidence?   
    And I think you should back off. You didn't read the theses, you don't know the program or even the university. Or me, for that matter.

    "impart" "wisdom"

    Please.
  4. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from Kuriakos in Is this over-confidence?   
    And I think you should back off. You didn't read the theses, you don't know the program or even the university. Or me, for that matter.

    "impart" "wisdom"

    Please.
  5. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from biotechie in Is this over-confidence?   
    And I think you should back off. You didn't read the theses, you don't know the program or even the university. Or me, for that matter.

    "impart" "wisdom"

    Please.
  6. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from Usmivka in Is this over-confidence?   
    As part of my due diligence for the program I've got my eye on for 2013, I've looked at some of the theses of past grads from the program.

    And they were....OK.

    I didn't look at them all, just ones that interested me or appeared to have something in common with my thesis topic. Of course I have no idea if I was looking at the best or worst ones, though the sample was pretty random, so it should have been a mix.

    Anyway, like I said, they were OK. I wasn't blown away by the brilliance of any of them and in some cases I was definitely unimpressed. No disrespect re: the time and effort it took to do them though.

    I've shifted my thinking from "I can probably do this" to "I can TOTALLY do this". It will be a lot of work but well within my intellectual capabilities.

    I don't know... perhaps my idea of what graduate work is all about was too high? Like only the super-smarties can do it and their work is always staggeringly original?

    Maybe all you need is a good brain, a decent idea and a fair chunk of self-discipline?
  7. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from Two Espressos in Is this over-confidence?   
    And I think you should back off. You didn't read the theses, you don't know the program or even the university. Or me, for that matter.

    "impart" "wisdom"

    Please.
  8. Downvote
    margarets reacted to Pauli in Is this over-confidence?   
    To margarets, I impart to you two lines of wisdom:
    Don't knock their theses until you've written a peer-reviewed approved one yourself.
    The successful focus for writing a grad schools thesis is contributing strong peer-reviewed knowledge of a specialized type of knowledge, not blowing away people on its impact. The latter may result from the former, but they're not equivalent.
    What incoming grad student applicants fail to realize was that a lot of trial and error research occur that lead to the final piece that is an approved thesis, but only the last successful stage of that work appears in the final draft.
  9. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from noodles.galaznik in Is this over-confidence?   
    As part of my due diligence for the program I've got my eye on for 2013, I've looked at some of the theses of past grads from the program.

    And they were....OK.

    I didn't look at them all, just ones that interested me or appeared to have something in common with my thesis topic. Of course I have no idea if I was looking at the best or worst ones, though the sample was pretty random, so it should have been a mix.

    Anyway, like I said, they were OK. I wasn't blown away by the brilliance of any of them and in some cases I was definitely unimpressed. No disrespect re: the time and effort it took to do them though.

    I've shifted my thinking from "I can probably do this" to "I can TOTALLY do this". It will be a lot of work but well within my intellectual capabilities.

    I don't know... perhaps my idea of what graduate work is all about was too high? Like only the super-smarties can do it and their work is always staggeringly original?

    Maybe all you need is a good brain, a decent idea and a fair chunk of self-discipline?
  10. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from sgp3213 in Is this over-confidence?   
    As part of my due diligence for the program I've got my eye on for 2013, I've looked at some of the theses of past grads from the program.

    And they were....OK.

    I didn't look at them all, just ones that interested me or appeared to have something in common with my thesis topic. Of course I have no idea if I was looking at the best or worst ones, though the sample was pretty random, so it should have been a mix.

    Anyway, like I said, they were OK. I wasn't blown away by the brilliance of any of them and in some cases I was definitely unimpressed. No disrespect re: the time and effort it took to do them though.

    I've shifted my thinking from "I can probably do this" to "I can TOTALLY do this". It will be a lot of work but well within my intellectual capabilities.

    I don't know... perhaps my idea of what graduate work is all about was too high? Like only the super-smarties can do it and their work is always staggeringly original?

    Maybe all you need is a good brain, a decent idea and a fair chunk of self-discipline?
  11. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from pinkrobot in Is this over-confidence?   
    As part of my due diligence for the program I've got my eye on for 2013, I've looked at some of the theses of past grads from the program.

    And they were....OK.

    I didn't look at them all, just ones that interested me or appeared to have something in common with my thesis topic. Of course I have no idea if I was looking at the best or worst ones, though the sample was pretty random, so it should have been a mix.

    Anyway, like I said, they were OK. I wasn't blown away by the brilliance of any of them and in some cases I was definitely unimpressed. No disrespect re: the time and effort it took to do them though.

    I've shifted my thinking from "I can probably do this" to "I can TOTALLY do this". It will be a lot of work but well within my intellectual capabilities.

    I don't know... perhaps my idea of what graduate work is all about was too high? Like only the super-smarties can do it and their work is always staggeringly original?

    Maybe all you need is a good brain, a decent idea and a fair chunk of self-discipline?
  12. Downvote
    margarets got a reaction from bluebunny in How do you interpret this email, is it rejection?   
    Remember that universities are massively bureaucratic. If they can add more useless, illogical steps to a straightforward process, they will. And the last thing they concern themselves with is the emotional wear and tear on the student.

    Hang in there.
  13. Upvote
    margarets got a reaction from R Deckard in How do you interpret this email, is it rejection?   
    Remember that universities are massively bureaucratic. If they can add more useless, illogical steps to a straightforward process, they will. And the last thing they concern themselves with is the emotional wear and tear on the student.

    Hang in there.
  14. Upvote
    margarets got a reaction from transcendental in How do you interpret this email, is it rejection?   
    Remember that universities are massively bureaucratic. If they can add more useless, illogical steps to a straightforward process, they will. And the last thing they concern themselves with is the emotional wear and tear on the student.

    Hang in there.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use