Just to chime in on this, I think the M.A. bias for some of these schools vary field by field. I've chatted with a few profs about this, who suggest fields like medieval and early modern candidates can be given an advantage at any program with an advanced degree by merit of the language and theory training that accompany them. Like you BGT28, I went to an elite undergraduate institution; however, I didn't do so well thanks to my coming from an impoverished community/family, and my M.A. (from a near-unknown school btw) helped me sharpen my language and theory and really show my love for the subject. I've been accepted this year to six of the top ten programs with a lackluster undergraduate GPA. I realize that a swallow does not make a summer, but having an M.A. isn't going to bar you from a Harvard/Yale/Penn/Columbia--I and several other folk I know are walking proof of this. Congratulations on your acceptance to NYU's M.A. too! It's much better than I did when I applied to M.A.s