Ok thats great advice. I guess after talking to you guys I'm not too worried about it but if there are schools who will take the highest scores and mix and match that would obviously be best. Otherwise I will probably just send in my second score as it sounds like it really isn't that big a deal. Its comforting to know that I'm not the only one who scored a 4 as well (even though I'm sure you are a great writer). Also my writing samples, SOP, and letters of recommendation are strong as far as I can tell so maybe its alright. Also congratulations on the fellowship!