I am really torn between these schools for different reasons. I think both have a lot to offer me.
I choose American because it is a Tier 1 school over all, and the School of Public Affairs is ranked 14 in the nation(Mason is a Tier 3, SPP ranked 45). I like that the classes are on the main campus with all of the amentities including a full library and student life, plus free parking after 5:30 p.m. I love the closeknit community feel of the school. I am against American because they are so dang expensive! Although my financial aid covers my tuition little to nothing is left over for other expenses.
I choose Mason because they are a 15 minutes drive from my house, I like the reaction I get from people when I mention the school, and they are very cheap. With my financial aid, I wouldn't have to work while in school(but I will anyways), I can afford extra classes over the summer, and live VERY comfortably while in school. This is a luxury I totally missed out on in undergrad. I also like that it is a large school with a very large alumni network, and more students for me to get to know. I don't like that Mason campuses are broken up all over the Northern VA region. The program I am going into is not on the main campus, it is a building in another city. I have heard Mason students aren't very social for some reason. While I believe their program is 'good', I don't think it is better than AU's.
Is American worth giving up the luxurious life style Mason is offering me?