MW06

I emailed Jeff Mantz again to see if there was any update on my proposal. I received a reply today (12/19). At least in my case, NSF has not received all the reviews and it will take another week or two before they make the final decision. I hope this helps.

My guess is that those of us with no mention of rating are not in the "must fund" category and placed somewhere down the ranking.

bipedalcycle, no, Mantz didn't mention rating. Perhaps mine wasn't as competitive as your colleague's.

Following Elk4's suggestion I also contacted Jeff Mantz and was told on the 11th that he didn't have enough information about my results. He said they would need a couple more weeks to finalize the recommendations and it's unlikely that they would be able to send us results or review comments quickly enough to permit the January 15 resubmission.