Thanks again for all the feedback. You guys have been extremely helpful and welcoming to me, despite this being my first post (and quite a 'woe is me' post at that).
As to the "why study at a Divinity school" I see I was very misinformed, and I completely get the point that has been made, and as to the point of “if you’re not a Christian, why are you here?” I experience something similar on a frequent basis. I often have to constantly justify myself to people when I tell them what I'm studying, I inevitably get asked "If you're not a Christian, then why are you studying religion." My first answer has always been that religion encompasses more than just Christianity, and this is more relevant to my BA, which has had a broader range of religion courses where I have chosen to narrow it down to interpretation and biblical classes in my electives, etc. I also like to tell people, "You don't need to be Egyptian to study Egyptology" not quite the same, but it makes my point I suppose.
As far as praying prior to class and such, I wouldn't mind that, I just want an environment where I can study without my personal beliefs being an issue. To date, this hasn't been a problem for the most part. I've run across a classmate or two who became angry with me over my "preposterous" beliefs of the Bible, and one teacher who I felt (perhaps imagined) was harder on my because of my beliefs, but it just made me work harder to produce quality work. The rest have been extremely open and I frequently have extensive discussions with one of my professors who is also a Lutheran Pastor regarding many biblical topics. I’m also very used to other students interjecting their personal beliefs in academic topics, I figure this comes with the territory. I just don’t want to treated poorly or even graded poorly because I don’t apply those same beliefs to my work.
Anyway, before I get too far off track, I brought up the suggestions here to one of my professors (one of my letters of recommendation) and she agreed that getting a second BA could help, but also warned getting one at CU could actually hinder my chances at getting accepted to CU’s Masters program because some schools prefer students to get a “diversified” education. Her recommendation was to apply to multiple MA programs and if I am not accepted to any of them, then I should look into bolstering my application with a second BA.
With that being said, I am actually highly encouraged about Iliff’s program. I’ve spoken to an admissions counselor and I discussed my hesitence about enrolling in a Christian based school and she assured me that regardless of my beliefs I would be warmly accepted and that they have many students from different backgrounds and faiths (or even lack thereof). I still have time to apply to Iliff for the 2014-2015 school year, and I think currently that’s my best choice. If I am not accepted, I will look into applying to multiple programs for next year.
I am encouraged by your information that some of the bigger name schools might be the perfect fit for me, and that I might actually have a shot at them, but I do have to wonder if it’s worth waiting a year for a chance, when I could apply to Iliff now. (of course there is no guarantee I’ll be accepted at Iliff either, but I feel it would be safer and more beneficial to try first, than to wait)