Now that my own process has somewhat concluded I can reply to this thread. Very interesting to read through these! 
 
Schools Applied To: NYU Wagner (MUP), UCL (MSc Int. Public Policy), Michigan Ford (MPP), Carnegie Mellon (MSPPM, OSU (MPA) 
Schools Admitted To: NYU ($0), UCL ($0), CMU ($21K Admitted to their Adelaide program instead of Pitt), OSU (Full Tuition + Stipend) 
Schools Rejected From: Michigan 
Schools Waitlisted At: None 
Still Waiting: None 
 
Undergraduate institution: University of Minnesota 
Undergraduate GPA: 3.54 
Last 60 hours of Undergraduate GPA (if applicable): NA 
Undergraduate Major: Marketing & Public/Non-Profit Management 
 
GRE Quantitative Score: 680 
GRE Verbal Score: 550 
GRE AW Score: 4.0 
 
Years Out of Undergrad (if applicable): 1 
Years of Work Experience: 1 Full Time 
Describe Relevant Work Experience: Current AmeriCorps VISTA, Former State Senate Intern 
 
Strength of SOP (be honest, describe the process, etc): I began the process without clear direction but as I thought about my journey to this point and my experiences (work, personal and education) everything became more clear and easier to write. I think I tied everything together really well...but who knows really.  
Strength of LOR's (be honest, describe the process, etc): I'd say average...this was probably my weakest part. 2 professors at the Humphrey Inst. whose classes I enjoyed most and excelled in. Also my VISTA supervisor.   
 
 
Other: I studied in Denmark for a semester which contributed to my reasons for wanting to focus on international public policy. Also when I was in high school I was an active City Council student rep. which also worked it's way into my SOP.  I intend to go into international economic development so that's why I think CMU admitted me to their Adelaide campus...I never applied or wanted to go there but after admission I did consider it. This process has definitely affirmed for me that most grad school admission committee really do take a thorough approach to each candidate and consider their long term goals in the selection process.  
 
Decision: Ultimately I will end up at UCL assuming no major financial aid from NYU.