Thank you for the responses! I focus on American Religious History, which I don't think Santa Cruz is known for, but the enthusiasm of my potential adviser(s) and the financial package have both been exceptional. Plus, I already live in the Central Coast and LOVE the Santa Cruz area, so the move would not be a difficult one. Its a stressful decision, though, and I would have to play my cards just right if I took it, as Heimat Historian said, through publishing and great LORs coming out of there.