I have applied to 11 biosciencey PhD programs at a decent range of quality of schools. My reach schools were WashU, UWisconsin (3 programs here) and UMichigan. My "safety/mid range" schools were Utah, Oregon Health and Science (2 programs here), Oregon, Cincinnati, Montana and Montana State. So far I have heard back from around half and the only two interviews I have gotten have been with "reach" programs. I have an interview with Wisconsin and Michigan. I have gotten rejected from Utah, Oregon, one program at Oregon Health and Science and WashU. What is even crazier to me is that I just did an REU at Utah with the same program I applied to. My GRE and GPA were all either at or higher than their average accepted applicant pool. The PI I had wrote a good enough letter to get me interviews with Wisconsin and Michigan so I feel like he liked me enough.
Anyone have any insight on what could be happening? It doesn't make any sense to me.