Hi everyone,
I'm applying to grad school next year so I was curious to scroll through this field. I hope someone with experience will sees my reply and can answer my question.
So as I saw the main argument was between top 10 schools and second runners. I do agree on the very fact that if you choose to pursue a PhD program, you have to aim for the best possible school in order to have opportunities within this highly competitive field. You argued that all major fellowships and academic positions go to the graduates of these top schools (fact, true unfortunately, that's how it usually works).
However, my question is, as a prospective graduate student, currently pursuing my Bachelor's in a low tier public school: how much of a chance do I stand to get into a top graduate school? As you mentioned, most employers (let that be major museums or universities) do not consider candidates who are graduates of lower tier schools, regardless of how smart and academic they are. Then do top schools consider applicants from lower tier schools at all?
I spoke to two professors of mine, one of them had my hopes up and the other had me down. One said anything is possible if my research topic is special enough, stands out and is well written. The other said that I made my choice for a life when I enrolled in a lower tier school for a Bachelor's and there is no way to break out from this. Then I went on the website of the top universities and scrolled through current PhD students, where the majority of them had their Bachelor's from other Ivy Institutions or already a Master's from a similarly well-established university. Then do my Honor's in the major, special and well-written research, high GPA, hopefully good GRE and language knowledge matter at all, if I am only coming from a low tier school? (when I mean low tier I do not indicate top 10-25, even lower than those).
When I chose to attend my school I did not pick it because this would have been the only place where I could get into based on my knowledge. I chose it because this was the only one I could afford.
So my question is, based on your own experience or on others' you know, is it worth aiming that high with a background like mine and spending hundreds of dollars on application fees to top schools? If you already say a few people did it, or someone did it, that's good enough for me, because then I know it's possible.