Jump to content

kwisco

Members
  • Posts

    18
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by kwisco

  1. 18 hours ago, Brynamakowka said:

    What happens if one gets a returned proposal? Do you think one would be given the opportunity to make corrections and re-submit? I haven't heard anything back yet but I looked on fastlane NSF website and saw the status of "reurned" just that word two days after it was submitted.  Now I am waiting until they are back after the holiday to call the Project Director. The one on call during the holiday didn't have any info on my status and he said I will get a email with full response. I'm pretty upset, could use some hope here. I still haven't gotten a proper notice from NSF so I am just speculating but feel pretty bad. Must be a formatting issue. 

    Bad news: I'm so sorry, I know how frustrating that is because it happened to me as a 1st year grad student. You put so much time, energy, and hope into your application that it super stinks when something as small as formatting causes your application to get kicked back. I was not allowed to resubmit that year.

    Good news: When mine was returned without review it did not count as a submission so I was allowed to submit again as a 2nd year grad student. In my case, I think my application was even better and my overall packet much stronger- and I happened to be awarded the fellowship last year!

    My advice is to be mad/sad/whatever ya gotta do and then keep on keeping on! You made a mistake and that stinks but I took it as a (painful) learning experience moving forward (and you better believe I triple check every single document margin lol). I hope you have another opportunity to submit in the future, good luck!!

  2. 11 minutes ago, cullenish said:

    If this goes anything like previous years, the site won't just go down without warning. There should be a little message somewhere saying in a few hours the site will go down. 

    Yes, exactly! Looks like this (as someone kindly posted earlier)

    On 3/22/2019 at 5:13 PM, caha9192 said:

    Is this a sign??

    Screen Shot 2019-03-22 at 3.10.53 PM.png

     
  3. No I do not think so. They extended the deadline for the reviewers to turn in their comments today actually, so I don’t think we need to start stressing until mid April at the earliest. 

  4. I heard information from my PI who is reviewing applications that the NSF had canceled the review panels because of the shutdown.

    Additionally, in order to keep maintain the timeline (~mid April) they were not planning to reschedule but rather make decisions based on the initial reviews. 

  5. 2 hours ago, GoldenDog said:

    Nah I applied this year as undergrad for the first time. However, from what I know, the reviewers havent provided feedback in the past. But the application was also different before (Up to third year PhD?). It seems like you as long as you meet their eligibility criteria (1st or second year grad student? I dont remember), there isnt a stipulation about number of apps...

     

    55 minutes ago, runrabbit said:

    I applied last year as an UG, and got rejected. You don’t receive any feedback. I’m applying this year as a 1st year PhD and from my understanding can re-apply next year too as a 2nd year. Pretty sure it only goes up to 2nd year though? Can someone confirm?

    Okay thanks for the info! I don’t have high hopes for this year so just want to start thinking ahead.

  6. 1 hour ago, GoldenDog said:

    I mean they said the same thing last year, by the 14th (Friday then). But they actually released on Tuesday the 11th. Also, the 15th is the deadline for many offers, so it'd be cruel sort of cruel to just release Friday afternoon and not really allow students time to work out some items. I think they'll release sooner, but maybe not!

    Those are some good points! So by the sounds of your last comment, it seems you were able to apply for a second time. Do you know the eligibility rules for reapplying? Is it once as undergrad/once as graduate student like NSF? Also did you receive feedback from reviewers on your application? I wasn’t able to find this information on the website. 

  7. 15 minutes ago, GoldenDog said:

    Anyone wana be the sacrificial lamb and call today? Ha ha ha

    I working under the notion that they won’t release until Friday. But will that stop me from constantly refreshing my email...nope! 

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use