Yup we got the same form letter -- you're mentioning the exact phrases I've been thinking were nice to read too. I made the decision to apply to MSW programs on very short notice and without much time, so I only have an application in at Smith and one at Westfield State.
I know some of the teachers in your area pretty well, I've sat a few retreats with Andrea Fella and I did a month at Spirit Rock a few years ago when I was living in Seattle. You're right that CIMC has a great community. I think there's also actually quite a bit of dharma in the Amherst/Northampton area as well beyond Smith -- although I haven't yet been to the local insight meditation group, which is in Easthampton. IMS is only 45 minutes away, but in a very rural area, so the community is mostly staff-oriented, but there are opportunities for volunteering, and tons of amazing teachers going through there, the Forest Refuge, and Barre Center for Buddhist Studies.
Wishing you luck and metta as well!