Both seem great, though highly different, options. At times, I find myself considering the schools through a Head/Heart dichotomy, where: Heart = Berkeley; Head = Princeton. This may be foolishness, but there it is.
***
Princeton Pros: Better stipend, less teaching, cheaper cost of living, proximate to New York and Philly, more funding for archival research, language study, and conference travel.
Princeton Cons: (Allegedly) more traditional and hierarchical, not exactly a vibrant town, smaller [possibly a pro], more self-enclosed, less pleasant weather/environment overall.
AND
Berkeley Pros: Beautiful area, lovely weather, more diversity (of people, ideas, environment), larger [could also be a con], more vibrant grad. student life and community, more life outside of campus, (allegedly) less hierarchical.
Berkeley Cons: Worse stipend, higher cost of living, more teaching, environmentally precarious area (earthquakes, droughts, wildfires, hyper-development), less funding for archival research, language study, travel.
***
Any help, advice, anecdotes, are appreciated tremendously!
Thank you.