Thanks guys for your replies!
spozik - to answer your question about what I want to do, I'm not exactly 100% sure, but I think I see myself in a museum setting. I would like to work in close proximity with the collections. I currently have an internship at the local art museum, and am also working in the Herpetology collection at the natural history museum (completely unrelated, I know). I actually go to UF, so FSU appeals to me because it is close by (no residency complications), funds most of its students, and has a museum certificate program. They appear to be less focused on languages than any other program I've seen. I'm not sure what my other options are in Classical Archaeology, besides teaching, which I don't see myself doing, at least not immediately. I appreciate your honesty about me dropping the Cicero class. I'm sure I could have passed if I stuck with it, but I was just in total panic mode and needed to make a decision during drop/add. I may have done myself a disservice, but nothing I can do about it now I suppose. Tufts is actually on my list, as well as UNC, but I feel I wouldn't be able to get into any of those schools based on my language experience... I may message you with more info about post bac. It seems practical, but I'm over my head in debt already and just can't afford it.
kemet - thanks for your reply! I definitely need to de-stress! I haven't looked too much into Art History programs, basically because its time consuming to weed through them all to find ones with focuses in Classics. I will check out the ones you mentioned.
kittie - Hmm.. I have not considered an MA in Humanities.. do you have any suggestions? I actually have been on one dig, it was last summer. It would be nice if I could do another one next summer or something before grad school, but that doesn't seem feasible. I am definitely going to consider Post Bacs, but you're right, they would destroy my finances. I worry that I won't do well, and looking at some of the programs, I don't even have enough language experience to get into them! Sigh.
I'm trying not to panic too much, but since I need to apply within the next few months it's difficult to stay calm. This week I am going to try to meet with a few faculty members for advice, and go from there. Hopefully a few years from now I'll look back at this post and laugh, with my MA in hand. Or maybe I'll become a massage therapist in 9 months. Who knows!