I don't mean to discourage you, but what kor_to_nola said is no longer true at least for Yale Divinity. Since YDS started giving a full funding stipend to all admitted students with demonstrated needs (from two years ago), it became more competitive to get in. I assume that's why MaryHildegard couldn't get accepted. The acceptance rate for YDS was already 24.5% by 2009, and got much more competitive in recent years due to the reason I mentioned above. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2009/02/11/applications-to-divinity-school-up-13-percent/. It means that the acceptance rate should me somewhere around 18-20% by now, but not 40-50% like it used to be in the 90's and early 00's.
If you are aiming for Master of Divinity, I would say give it a shot. Academic performance is not the primary thing that divinity schools consider for MDiv applicants. You can also put BU, Emory, Vandy, and Duke in your radar as kor_to_nola and MaryHildegard recommended.