Good luck to everyone applying! It’s exciting to see the diverse programs and combinations being pursued. The anxiety is real, but we’ve got this - one step closer to the dream!
Thank you for such a candid perspective. It’s a sobering reminder of the reality many PhDs face, especially in history. While the intellectual journey has its merits, the opportunity cost is undeniably significant. It’s a tricky path, prospective students should weigh these insights carefully.
Your profile is super impressive! While publications help, your strong academic record, GRE scores, and research experience (even if not published) make you a competitive candidate. I agree with adding a few mid-range schools like Texas or Illinois to balance the list. And for recommendations, go with someone who knows you well - it'll carry more weight than a generic letter. Good luck!