E1: Global Change here, based in Illinois. Got my rejection packet in the mail this morning. Mine also had 3 full reviews in it: 1 Excellent, 1 Very Good, 1 Good. Interestingly, my Good reviewer didn't trash my proposal at all ... just raised a few legitimate concerns. I'm thinking my advisor and I will turn this application into an NIH grant instead. All of my reviewers agreed that my project was a cool idea, just maybe not the most appropriate topic for EPA.