I got E/VG, E/E, VG/VG. Applied in Chemistry and awarded HM, didn't get anything last year, but had lower scores. Reviewers like my broader impacts, one noted that I should provide more detail regarding broader impacts following graduate study.
For one VG in IM, reviewer said that I should give examples of potential drugs my proposal could apply to, but I though this was a NSF no-no. Going to apply next year, hopefully I'm just moving up the ladder! I like dreaming that they will give some HM's the award after people decline, but haven't heard enough cases of this to think it possible to happen.
