Hi! I'm not sure of what future you are working toward (stay in business? go to law school? get a master's degree now and MBA later?), so it's difficult to weigh in on whether Fordham or Scranton is better for you.
I can tell you that both my husband and I attended Scranton for undergrad a few years ago and loved it. After a few years in business, my husband got his MBA at nearby Wilkes University and is now beginning the Duquesne School of Law (a path similar to your proposal). The admissions officer we spoke to at Duquesne seemed to highly respect the University of Scranton, and I know of many success stories from friends who have attended or are attending the MBA program at Scranton. A side note regarding the above poster's concerns about career placement: the Career Services Office at the U is fabulous and will provide assistance to any U of S graduate.
Ultimately, if your goals are to go to law school, I'd suggest spending some serious time preparing for the LSAT, as that score seems to be a substantial determining factor in admissions decisions. Many law schools don't even consider your education beyond undergrad.
Good luck with your decision. Either way, you'll be attending a fine Jesuit institution! Again, best of luck!