Yes, absolutely. The perk of being in the capital offset some of my initial hesitations. I would be more than happy to attend Carleton for the reasons you've listed (and they have quite an interesting faculty). If I receive other positive offers I'm going to have a difficult decision in front of me.
I agree about McGill, the interests of the faculty seem to be less, er, wide-sweeping. I actually applied for the development studies options to try to take a more interdisciplinary approach in a department that I think could use some more interesting hires. I already live in Montreal, so there is a convenience factor for me. I understand the hesitation about Toronto completely; I think that my dad would be heartbroken if I attended UofT. They also don't tend to fund masters students. I'm originally from Toronto which is why those universities are particularly appealing to me (I can return home!). So many different variables in this process, amiright?
According to the results page, notices are out for UofT on Friday just in case anyone missed that...