How long did it take before you heard from them? I emailed them on Tuesday morning because I had a 2 point discrepency on my publications a 1.5 and a 3.5. I have 2 papers (not first author, but it is VERY VERY rare to have a first author paper before your 2nd or 3rd year PhD in Psychology) and a ton of conference presentations at the national and international level. We are almost wondering if it could be a typo- a 1.5- seriously?? I also had about three other 1 point discrepencies, and absolutely no comments from one reviewer. Did anyone else get weird reviews like that?
Someone asked about the rankings, I was ranked 348 and my average was 4.12, cutoff had to be at least 4.4 or higher this year. My supervisor said the competetion is getting ridiculous and she is a chair.