History PhD with a theology masters?

[historyreligion]

I’m currently preparing to apply to PhD programs for Fall 2022. Broadly, my interests are in the history of American Christianity (nineteenth to early twentieth century), environmental history, settler-colonialism, and imperialism. Considering history, American studies, and religion programs, but leaning toward history.

I just completed a Master of Divinity in theological studies with a focus on environmental justice/eco-theology. Because of this I am a little wary of applying directly to history PhD programs. Would a theology degree, even one from a research university, be considered a red flag since the MDiv is traditionally a professional degree for religious professionals (FWIW, I was in the academic track, as opposed to the pastoral track)?

I initially did the degree as prep for a religion or theology PhD, but as I progressed I realized I was drawn more toward a historical approach to studying religion (I took several history classes in my master’s program and did my undergrad in history). Likewise, I haven’t found any theology or religion doctoral programs that fit my interests and are fully funded. Thinking long-term, I’d rather teach in a history department than a religion department or seminary, though I’m aware that the job market is tough and I am open to career paths outside academia.

In my favor, I have a BA in American History from a secular liberal arts school where I did a summer research project with a history professor. I have two conference presentations under my belt so far and am spending the next year and a half working on languages and honing a writing sample. However, my GPA was lacking. My undergrad GPA was 3.29 (3.51 in my major), compared to my M.Div. GPA of 3.89. I also haven’t published anything yet. 

Between my low undergrad GPA and unconventional master’s program, I’m wondering if folks have any advice. Do I stand a chance getting into history (or American Studies) PhD programs? Should I aim for a religion PhD? Or should I apply for a second master’s in history (I want to avoid this due to the cost but fear it may be the only option)?

Edited November 11, 2020 by historyreligion

[dr. t]

16 hours ago, historyreligion said:

Would a theology degree, even one from a research university, be considered a red flag since the MDiv is traditionally a professional degree for religious professionals (FWIW, I was in the academic track, as opposed to the pastoral track)?

No, you're fine.