Letters of Reference

[CG66]

Hello All,

I am applying to grad schools for Neuroscience. I am trying to find out who I would like to write letters of reference. I have 2 people already, professors, but I was wondering if it would be appropriate to ask my boss. I currently work at a University/Medical school, as a lab tech, and do various things around the lab. Should I just find another professor?

What do y'all think?

Thanks in Advance

[solefolia]

Someone might have a different answer for this (I've heard mixed feelings on having a boss write a LoR)...

Do you think your boss can vouch for your academic/scholarly ability, based on your work? How much independence do you have, as far as being able to show your own abilities, rather than just follow directions? personally, I think if you feel your boss knows you better and can write about your potential as a graduate student, then you'd be better served asking him/her for a recommendation. If not, go with the professor. Overall, I think so long as you're not a retail worker, asking your boss for a recommendation is completely appropriate if they are the best choice/know you best.

[belevitt]

Are you kidding? Why do you have to ask this question at all? Of course your PI is the best LOR writer you could have. He is somebody who can judge your abilities as a researcher.

[GAB]

I'm applying to Molec & Cell Ph.D. programs.

Firstly, in response to original query, I concur with the other respondents in that your boss/lab PI is a good reference in your case.

I have two quick related questions:

1. Should I or should I not waive my right to examine my recommendations/letters of reference? Why or why not?

2. I have 5 references. Is it alright/recommended to have more than 3? I assume it is.

Many thanks

[solefolia]

I can't give you a definite answer for either but from what I understand...

1. Not waiving your right is considered a big faux pas. If you are worried about what your recommenders might say, then chances are, they aren't a good source for a recommendation.

2. Sending more than 3 won't be a problem. I've heard of many people sending in four. Sometimes all of them are read, sometimes only the first three. Five might be pushing it, but I can't imagine it would hurt you. The worst that could happen is that they only take the first three.

[GAB]

Thanks for the quick response. That's what I figured, but nice to get confirmation.