M.A. Thesis & Ph.D. Applications

[Matt12710]

How important is writing a thesis if someone plans to apply to doctoral programs in the future? Some master's programs have a thesis or non-thesis option. I can see the pros and cons of each, but would a thesis be the best option because it shows research ability and experience? Or does it matter? A thesis isn't the only kind of research experience. Insight is appreciated. 

[Willows]

I applied and have been accepted without a thesis. That said, if I were going the MA route, I would do the thesis option. It's more than just showing ability and research, it can help you discover where your interests are -- or better yet, where they aren't. In many cases, you can build on the thesis your thesis instead of starting from scratch at the doctorate level, which is naturally a good thing when multiple PhD programs give you less time to finish and/or funding for fewer years if you come in with a Master's. 

[Matt12710]

Did you apply without a master's and just with a B.A.? Or did you earn a non-thesis master's? 

[heathenist]

My program doesn't have a "thesis," but instead, it's a "master's research paper."  It's still original research, but it's much shorter and you don't have to defend it (though you still need a committee).  I like this option for a few reasons; less stressful, less work, but most importantly, the finished product is closer to being a publishable paper than a thesis would be.  So with a thesis, my impression is, you do quite a bit more work/writing, but then have to cut it down if you want it published.  With a master's paper, you can submit it to journals when your done and you still have research experience.

 

However, if the option is between doing a thesis, or taking some type of comprehensive exam, I'd go with the thesis for the research experience.

[Willows]

Did you apply without a master's and just with a B.A.? Or did you earn a non-thesis master's? 

 

Just a Bachelor's + independent research. 

 

I did consider several MA programs at one point, and I chose schools that had "PhD placement" tracks, which of course urge you to write a thesis. I can PM you a few if you want!

Edited February 22, 2013 by Willows