Thanks guys and gals. I'm happy to hear that from people who have actually attended these institutions. I've never even taken a class at any college like that! I was accepted to Columbia, Yale, Vandy, and NYU for my undergrad, but was offered a boatload of money by a top-tier public school, so that's where I wound up. I couldn't be happier either, because that's where I met my wife
It is funny though, we both planned on attending NYU, but then decided against it at the last minute. So if things had gone a little differently, we could have met there instead. In my case, Columbia & Yale offered me a pittance, less than tuition, and Vanderbilt offered me litterally $0. NYU offered me tuition, probably because I would have been a legacy--that's my family's alma mater for undergrad, master's, and doctorate. I just couldn't go through with living like a relative pauper for four years in Manhattan though, when I could live really nicely at a public university also in the top 50.
jdmhotness, I did notice that about Duke! I have to say I was surprised by that! The majority of Duke grad students are coming from public undergrads. I was expecting half would be Tulane, Emory, Vandy, and Rice; the other half would be a mix of other top-tier universities, and the odd public institution. Even though it's smack in the middle of the doctoral programs my wife is considering, ranking-wise that is, she thinks she will probably wind up there, even if she gets offers from them all.
Slightly off topic, how do you like living in the Raleigh Triangle area? Any recommendations on neighborhoods? I've heard good things about Cary, NC, mostly because I'm a New Yorker, and it sounds like that's where most of us wind up. The Hillsborough Historic neighborhood sounds really interesting too...