I'll begin the Round 2 of Grad School apps to Public Policy programs in about a month or so. Round 1 involved applying to Harvard, Carnegie Mellon, U of Texas, Tufts, and U of Chicago. I was rejected at all except Chicago, where I was wait-listed. My GPA is 3.8 from a regional school (BA in Economics, graduated this Spring '09) and my GRE scores were 670v / 780q / 5w (95% / 90% / 77%). I feel good about those.
The reasons I suspect I got rejected in Round 1 are:
[*:1hrpfhmq]My resume includes 10 years of private-sector experience only, and all of a technical nature, and nothing that's particularly impressive.
[*:1hrpfhmq]Of my 3 recommendations, 2 were from professors I had good relationships with, and 1 was from my immediate supervisor at work (lower to middle management). Of the 2 professors, only 1 really publishes much and is active in the academic community.
[*:1hrpfhmq]My personal statements and other essays were written hastily and without adequate proof-reading and revising.
[*:1hrpfhmq]My applications were turned in on the deadline dates in most cases, and a couple were missing things like transcripts too that I had to turn in after the universities contacted me.
I think the last two were the most hurtful to my application. My recommendations could be better too, but I don't know that there's much I'll be able to do about that between now and December. Same goes for the resume. The things I'll do differently for Round 2 are:
[*:1hrpfhmq]Have my resume looked at by a few academics at my undergrad school. Perhaps there's a better way to format or highlight appealing aspects of my experience.
[*:1hrpfhmq]Volunteer time with a local charity or find a government internship. Either could be good to add to the resume and to perhaps secure a better recommendation.
[*:1hrpfhmq]Do better research on schools to find good opportunities for full tuition aid and programs more focused on my interests (International Trade & Economic Development)
[*:1hrpfhmq]Most importantly, dedicate more time to get applications submitted ahead of the early deadlines (early and often). This includes getting essays reviewed and proof-read, of course.
Suggestions, questions, and comments are welcome. Thanks to the others for posting your plans as well, it's helpful to read.