Here's a gem from my NYU acceptance letter: "NYU's offer is not only financially very lucrative..." I look forward to comparing their offer to Columbia's fellowship.
I applied chemical biology/physical chemistry. Apparently the prof was trying to call me and not getting through so he sent me an email. I don't know what the problem was because I have been staring at my cell since December! Ha!
Good luck!
ETA: on my phone messing things up sorry!
I am glad! I think they take a holistic view of your potential as a scientist, not just your standardized testing skills, lol. I think my recs were great. I graduated in 2012 and have been working as a lab tech/pretend graduate student since then. I would imagine that the letter from my current PI attesting to my success driving a project forward was the strongest part of my application.
Good luck!
I got into Caltech! I'll post my stats to reassure future applicants who bomb the chem GRE: 3.52 gpa from a SLAC, 3 years ugrad research, 1.5 years as a lab tech/pseudo grad student, one 5th author pub, a few posters, 161Q/163V/5.0, and, the killer: a 600 on the chem GRE. That's the 20th percentile. So don't despair, future applicants! It might not be a big deal.