I thought I was a perfect fit for Rutgers.
Anyone else seem to feel that no matter how great your fit, your SOP and your writing sample, sometimes the dice just aren't rolled in your favor. With these schools accepting 5% of applicants it almost seems like winning the lottery. Either that or my SoP and writing sample (which I worked heavily on and had other people read and comment and say they were good) really are just missing something, that elusive something that some students have and some don't.
Anyways, congrats to all the admits. Rutgers is an English PhD student's wet dream. Enjoy it for the rest of us!