thatsnotmyname
-
Posts
53 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by thatsnotmyname
-
-
If you think the Master's could seriously add something to your application then do that, but otherwise, I would not recommend it. One, Cornell is excellent in IR and East Asia, and outside of HYP I personally can not think of a better place to be to study that kind of stuff. I can't speak to Georgetown, but my close mentor has consistently stressed to me how strong Cornell is in IR/CP and Asia. Personally, I am in CP, but I imagine I will certainly be dabbling in IR, so the school has a great fit for that. Two, the application cycle was really tough this year, and I don't think next year will be any easier. This isn't to say you aren't qualified enough to do well next time you apply, but it certainly is a risk.
If there is any possibility you could see yourself working a non-academic job with a Master's in hand then Chicago makes sense. Otherwise, I would go for whichever PhD program you prefer. I don't know that an additional two years would help you that much more. I am coming from a more policy oriented Master's program where I certainly learned a lot, but also had to spend time taking courses that are not relevant to my eventual studies. I don't regret it because I rolled my degree into my BA and finished in four years, while being funded. Your case is certainly more different and involves a greater cost and risk.
Of course, this is all conjecture and opinion from someone who is just as unknowing as these things as you. I would recommend asking your letter writers what they think about the situation.
And of course, congratulations on your acceptances! Will you be attending the Cornell open house?
-
Hey thatsnotmyname! It would be great if you could share the details of the Cornell open house once you get back - I unfortunately can't make it because of other visits.. But would love to hear about what you gathered on the program.
I would be happy to! I will probably send a message to you (and anyone else unable to make it) just so I don't clog up the thread/forum will another topic.
-
Great thread AP! I am only visiting two schools- Cornell and UPenn both in the third week of March. Should be a good experience and will hopefully give me some good information on the schools.
And Rossiya- I am surprised that Madison's visit dates are so late- you would think with an April 15th decision date they would want to have people visit earlier.
-
Cornell is a great match for your interest in South Asia. If I remember correctly, a South Asianist placed very well last year and got a slew of offers.
Thank you! Yeah, UPenn is also great for South Asia so this is going to be a really tough call to make. I wish I knew when the rest of the admits/rejects/waitlist were coming out so everyone can put this school to rest.
-
Thanks everyone! There aren't many details to give. I think it was a generic email with my name on it from the Chair of the Admissions Committee and Director of the Graduate Studies. It came about 4:45 est. There were four hundred applicants which is their biggest pool ever. Scary.
Our good friend Tina Slater was cced on it though! Not sure if that is an important detail but there you go. Oh, also I am comparative politics- feel like I have a great fit there so now it's time to start making decisions.
They say happiness means having options. For someone as indecisive as me that may not be a good thing
-
OMG. Just accepted at Cornell. Literally shaking as I type this.
Funding comes tomorrow. No word on visit days. Can't think right now.
- NEPA, unclejoecannon and interista
-
3
-
Got an official no from Yale today for the MA. I feel pretty led on. This one actually really hurts.
I'm sorry to hear that! I can understand how you feel led on. Hopefully you hear back soon from some other schools!
-
Somebody, somewhere is not telling the whole truth.
Drama!
Congrats to those who got in!
-
No insider info on my part, not even one of my schools (with my numbers, the logical choice was to spend $70 on a steak dinner with a special someone rather than on an application to Harvard. Nothing against it though, as my mom went to their business school)
Anyways, for some reason this posted before I could finish typing (pressed enter too many times maybe?). What I was going to type is: That said, it does seem that many schools, particularly the Ivy Leagues, have been hewing closely to their patterns from 2009 almost to the day. Last year, Harvard sent out acceptances on Wednesday and Thursday during the last week of February. Perhaps that provides some clues as to what we should expect this year?
The app fee was actual 105. I still am trying to justified why I spent my money on somewhere I'm not going to get in
I agree, UPenn got back exactly at the same time as last year. It is true that Cornell is going to be taking a bit longer than last year by accepting people in March. Funny story, when I called Cornell for a status update, Tina Slater explicitly said all gradcafe result page posts were fake. Good to know they know about the trolls too.
-
Congrats! Man I was hoping to get in there. Really odd that they were working at 11am on a Sunday, no?
Thanks! Yeah, was not expecting a weekend update at all. I'm in comparative so its possible they are going by subfield. And I think the waitlist should come out soon. Good luck to you!
Also- JollyWag, are you going to the visit days? I'm not sure if I can make it out at that time...
-
I'm in at Washington. Mass email around 11 am Seattle time. They are putting funding packages together... Pretty excited but now I have to actually decide between schools by April. I was hoping to not to have to be in this position but I guess I can't complain
-
Judo!
Ninjas.
-
Russia
Anastasia
-
Has anyone here been rejected from nyu or princeton? I'm in the theory boat ... 790v 750q 3.85 from a top30 lac and I've been accepted nowhere (I also went to a top 20 law school and want to do public law as well). I'm wondering if adcomms are just not taking in theory folks - maybe because were the biggest risk in terms of placement?
I have not been official rejected from NYU or Princeton, all though in all likelihood I didn't make the cut. I don't think any of these schools have sent out official rejections, so there may be hope for you! Theory is tough, but hopefully your public law interest will balance that out and get you in at one of your top choices.
-
I don't want to rain on anyone's parade here or sound unsympathetic, but I find it a bit baffling that people who have been accepted to some great programs (Michigan, Texas, UVA...) are complaining. I think it's offensive and disheartening to those who have yet to get in anywhere and are truly worrying. Sure, I've been rejected at a few of my top choices, but I've also got some acceptances and I'm thrilled. We can't all expect to get into our dream school (well, except maybe SuddenlyParanoid). Try to look on the bright side of things.
Agreed. To each his/her own, but even if you don't get into the top ten you can still be successful. Life is about defining yourself for you, not for how others perceive you. I am honestly happy to be in at one school, and if I get rejected from everywhere else (yes even Harvard) I won't be upset at all. Then again being accepted at my top choice certainly helps.
To all of those who are still waiting, hang in there! I know it's really tough. I find that when I don't spend time obsessively checking email or thinking about it I hear more news
Murphy's Law maybe? -
Im in comparative and in at Penn. I know that's not the same as IR, so its possible they are staggering decisions...
-
Congrats to the Princeton admits!! I'm surprisingly not upset about not getting an email- then again getting accepted from UPenn the same day help
I think all schools should send out notifications on the same day so people don't have to be too upset about one rejection until the next acceptance. If that makes sense at all. -
In at Penn!!! I can hardly believe it
Full funding information forthcoming. -
no change
inconclusive results
-
bob keohane!
Princeton (sorry slightly lame association
) -
according to their academic calendar, they are open today. maybe they just need more time to figure out whom to admit and whom to waitlist.
does anyone know what's going on with berkeley? if they are done with acceptances, it seems like it would be easy enough to just send out a rejection email blast, but since they said they're going to be sending out decisions for the rest of the week, maybe they still have some acceptances and waitlists to send out? has anyone been rejected yet?
I haven't gotten an outright rejection yet, but that doesn't mean much. It's possible a huge stack of rejection letters is sitting on the grad directors desk just waiting to be sent out-afterall sending out rejections is hardly a priority. Even though they said they are sending out decisions all week I'm not holding out hope for them.
-
I like how the board was relatively quiet over the weekend, and come Monday morning we're all back! At least there weren't anymore fake postings on the results page this weekend
Good luck everyone, its going to be a looooooooooong week. -
To the person who has made my reputation go from a positive value to -11 to -22 right now: I have contacted the site administrators. You will be reprimanded.
Ziz: I have absolutely no idea.
This whole negative points thing is ridiculous. I hope administration can sort out where they are all coming from.
-
Rejected at Yale too. Ah well. At least I know one way or another now
All though I worry what this one rejection means for the rest of my apps...eek!
Fall 2010 Admission Results
in Political Science Forum
Posted
Ditto! I hope everyone's visits are going well, I imagine that's why it is so silent around these parts...