Hi Milkways,
I have not heard from all schools yet, but I have an interview with Hunter 3/13, and am assuming that Columbia has rejected me despite not having heard anything.
Rutgers is the only acceptance that I've received up to now and it came with VERY big funding (I don't feel comfortable saying the amount, but it is truly very big). I live in NYC, so if I get into Hunter also (which does not give funding at all), I am going to have a difficult time deciding.
Hunter is relatively inexpensive, I won't have to relocate or buy a car, I have a bit of a network there already, and I'll be able to continue with my current job (although with a reduced schedule). With Rutgers, there'll be much more of an adjustment.
I'm leaning toward the money, but reserving judgement... also welcoming input and recommendations from all!