I've been silently reading this thread for weeks, but I figured I might as well say hello. These are the programs I applied to:
NYU MS DS (accepted)
Johns Hopkins MS in Applied Math and Statistics (accepted)
Boston University MS in Statistical Practice (accepted; deadline to enroll has passed)
Boston University MA in Statistics (accepted)
Columbia MS in Data Science (waiting to hear; just did my one-way interview this morning)
I'm inclined towards NYU (I put in my deposit as well) for a few reasons: it's in NYC, where I am, so I don't have to uproot my life; it's two years and thus seems like it can cover more ground than many other programs I looked at; it has a core curriculum that's explicitly designed for the program, rather than borrowing miscellaneous courses from other departments. My only concern is that maybe a degree in "Data Science" will not be viewed as favorably by potential employers as a more "classic" degree like on in statistics or computer science.
I attended the NYU open house a week or so ago and was very impressed by what I saw and heard.
And since everyone is commenting on it, I'll jump in too: @nyan_cat what is your math background?