Hello!
Current MA student of the IFA. While I can’t speak to other people’s experiences with mentorship, I’ve certainly enjoyed my time there and found faculty to be supportive, responsive, and easily accessible. I think it’s important to note that at any institution you attend your ability to build relationships and rapport with faculty is up to you. It’s easier for PhD students to have closer relationships with faculty, in my opinion, because they are working almost exclusively with that faculty member or members in the pursuit of a topic in which they are both actively engaged in and researching, and have been chosen by that faculty member to do so. As someone who has a broad range of interests in the field, I’ve still found it easy to talk to various faculty even those outside of my fields of interest. All have been incredibly helpful and supportive. Again, I have to reiterate, that it is up to you as the student to pursue these relationships though! I am someone who works to actively participate in class and to regularly meet with faculty during office hours to follow up regarding questions I had about that class or upcoming projects. Because of this, I’ve become close to several faculty members and they have consistently referred me for Internship and job opportunities that they know fit my interests and skill set. I’m not someone who plans to continue on in academia, so I’ve greatly benefitted from the contacts I’ve made at various museum institutions throughout the city, many of whom I have been introduced to by faculty and the administration. As an add-on the IFA PhD and MA programs are much larger than most, so that may be part of the reason some may feel less able to develop close relationships with faculty or find it difficult to do so, there are simply way more students than faculty. However, this has not personally impeded my ability to interact with faculty.
In terms of it being a cash cow, I found the costs comparable to the other school I applied to, which was Tufts. In weighing the pros and cons of attending each, I ultimately settled on the IFA because it was going to be cheaper for me to attend (I live with family members in the city and don’t pay for rent) and allowed me greater access to museums and arts institutions (in-line with my future career goals). Both schools, it’s important to note, were incredibly kind and helpful in answering my questions as I prepared! I think pretty much any MA program in Art History is going to be expensive and leave you in a lot of debt, unfortunately. It’s a matter of deciding which schools are going to provide you the greatest opportunities for reaching your professional goals whether that be faculty that are doing research in a topic you are interested or other resources.
As an end note, someone implied that Columbia and the IFA don’t have stellar reputations in academic circles, I would disagree with that. Especially considering that many, if not most of, the MA students I know who have applied to PhD programs have gotten into top programs and/or their preferred program of study.
Anyway! Hope this helps! Feel free to reach out if you have any additional questions!