Depends on if funding is an issue for you. If funding is an issue, then you'll presumably want to go to an institution that will give you some sort of stipend while you get the MA. A place like Miami of Ohio is excellent, from what I've seen. If funding is not an issue, then your best bet is to try to get into one of the top continental programs as an MA seeking student: BC or DePaul, for instance. If you'd like to get an MA in the Chicago area in a continental program, I'd advise DePaul first, and then either Loyola or Northwestern. Best of luck.
