There are entire threads dedicated to what you will be evaluated based on/what matters...and now I have the ability to actually share it. This is not my normal profile, I don't want to be identified/get in trouble for sharing. I hope it helps some of you to understand this year's results and helps those preparing for future years. This is for a program that does consider the GRE (although, they are in talks to not include this in the future so I am unsure which parts of the rubric change or if the point totals just decrease).
This is just for one university (and is not finalized, it is being reworked):
Component & Max Points
Points values
Research
Max = 4
3: Outstanding; includes publications, presentations, awards, etc.
2: Good; includes UG research experience or work related research experience
1: Limited
0: No research experience
+1 extra for McNair Scholar, Honors thesis, etc.
Letters of Recommendation
Max = 3
3: very strong letters
2: moderately strong letters
1: average letters
-1: below average / red flag in letters
Sociological/social science knowledge / experience
Max = 2
2: sociology major; substantial experience
1: other social science major; substantial social science coursework
0: no social science coursework
UGPA
Max = 3
3: 3.7 to 4.0
2: 3.2 to 3.69
1: 3.0 to 3.19
0: < 3.0
Personal statement
Max = 5
4: strong fit in Sociology + Faculty
3: good fit in Sociology + Faculty
2: good fit in Sociology OR Faculty
1: unclear fit in Sociology + Faculty
0: poor fit in Sociology + Faculty
+1 extra for hardship, disadvantage
Writing Sample
Max = 3
3: Strong; Excellent framing/flow/writing
2:
1: Adequate
0: Weak; Poor framing/flow/writing
GRE Quantitative Reasoning
Max = 2
2: above 70th percentile
1: > 30th and < 70th
0: less than 30th
GRE Analytical Writing
Max = 2
2: above 70th percentile
1: > 40th to < 70th
0: less than 40th
GRE Verbal Reasoning
Max = 1
1: Above/equal to the 40th percentile
0: below 40th percentile
Total Score:
20–25: 1st tier
15–19: 2nd tier
0–14: 3rd tier / do not admit