Blah, looks like I'll be applying again in the fall!
Weirdly, my committee was split into (at least) 3 sub-committees (my friend in my cohort was put in a different one) and my subcommittee had a significantly higher cutoff score for the last funded application than theirs (9.75 vs 9.15). Makes it even more painful that my score would have gotten me in easy in a different sub-committee!
Third time's the charm? Hopefully?