Rollofthedice:
You seem like you fit at either school. Wilken at Virginia would be another great resource for you if he is not retiring soon.
I am interested in Christology and Phenomenology--specifically the French version (Marion, Henry, Lacoste, Levinas, etc) as well as Heidegger. Obviously, Kevin Hart at Virginia would be great to work with as well as Jones and Mathewes. Getting into that program has gotten immensely more difficult over the last few years, or so I hear--which means I am preparing myself for a rejection there. I am interested in Fordham because of the many there who work on the atonement, especially Viladeseau. I like the work of Papanikolaou too. Have you contacted anyone at Virginia? If so, how were they in responding? Some programs the faculty get back to you easily and some, like Princeton's Religion dept, act like they don't receive prospective student inquiries, which annoys me. and where did you get your MTS? I'm curious.