As much as I want to avoid speculating what the HDS adcom was looking for, I can't help but to make a few assumptions after reading of others being rejected with similar stats/educational background who applied for the MTS degree. I graduated cum lauda from a competitive liberal arts school in New England (which not to pat myself too much on the back, would be a magna at many other schools because there was no grade inflation cough cough...), had stellar recommendations, and corporate work experience to demonstrate the maturity in my decision to return to graduate school. I have a bend towards social justice, but as others who apply for the more academic MTS degree admit, my interests are not so much in volunteerism/activism as they are in advancing theological discussion. Yes, I realize I'm going to take heat for that statement.
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but here's what I would argue HDS is trying to do: change their image from elitist/liberal northeast divinity school to the beacon of social justice by welcoming very untraditional students, most of whom are from disadvantaged backgrounds or lesser known academic institutions. What is going to get HDS attention in the news? That a student/professor submitted a brilliant paper to a well-recognized journal? No, no one in the media cares about that, and therefore, no one cares to donate to such a program. Now, what about a story of the disadvantaged student who was granted such a fabulous opportunity to change the world through the resources at HDS? Yes, more mediable and therefore bigger bucks. I'm getting the impression that HDS is less interested in doing theology than they are demonstrating how involved they are in social justice. It just won't bring in any funding, from donors and the larger university if they do traditional theology anymore. I would even bet that the MTS degree, or at least some of the concentrations, get roped into the MDiv over the next few years.
Am I a bitter? No, but of course I'll admit that it stings. Does everyone else deserve their acceptances? Asbofrickenlutely, everyone here is intelligent, has a story to tell, and can truly offer any of these programs something unique.
OK- go ahead, rip into this.