glowingbrightly

If you actually made it official with paperwork then yes, it’s a contract. If you are unsure and would rather attend a waitlist program, then it’s best to wait until you know for sure or have to decide. While any program of course appreciates enthusiastic acceptances, they will look at you more favorably if you just keep them waiting than if you commit and drop them last minute.

yeah, there was a post claiming someone got the call weeks before other acceptances were reported

OP never followed up so no way to know—entirely possible they made an early call to a priority candidate but it seemed increasingly like a hoax

it looks like a few on draft got it—says will update by may 1st. hard to know if everyone did but this seems different from the vague pitt email that everyone got.

Yeah it’s focused towards the poetry side and mostly considering things like faculty and program vibes. While we all need to survive, I don’t really think stipend amount should be relevant to deciding where best to practice, and teaching load also shouldn’t be overlooked. It isn’t that IU or UIUC doesn’t welcome experimentalism or translation work—the question is what program is best to grow the kind of work that Magnolia is making. Personally, I considered applying to all of these schools but I just didn’t see myself in the faculty’s work so I don’t think it would have been the right fit, whereas the program I ended up at has two amazing faculty that I see myself in deeply and who are also compelled by my work—I wouldn’t trade that for almost anything, especially a few thousand dollars or a guaranteed third year.

oh no I hadn’t heard about poetry issues at WashU. I’m a poet too so I could offer a bit more direct advice if I knew what your own poetry was like and what your goals for it are. I think, because you have such great potential options, this really comes down to vibes more than anything else. Broadly, ND is going to be weirder and more into translation, IU is more supportive/craft-focused, and UIUC will be more interdisciplinary/socially conscious.

I think you have four amazing waitlists and you’d be lucky to get off any one. WashU is up there a bit more in prestige but Notre Dame and Indiana have really solid reputations, and UIUC also looks lovely. You are probably right about Indiana being a bit more known than ND but ND has more reach in experimental circles (Action Books) while IU leans more traditional. I think they all have similarities in terms of LCOL but still decent midwest locations, funding, prestige so I’d choose solely based on how you vibe with faculty work.

2:2 is a lot but if you think the program seems great and love the faculty then that’s all you should need to know imo

acceptances came out a few weeks ago. I got one but am going to turn it down. I haven’t seen any rejections or waitlists and it’s a big, expensive program so you’d think there’d be a lot.

I refused to apply to any programs that had interviews and now I feel very justified in that choice but here’s hoping pitt and others still work out for folx!

For sure, it’s a big program so lots of waitlist movement but it’ll happen late cus most aren’t rejecting Iowa first thing. I know of at least a couple acceptances visiting this week that haven’t decided yet.

syracuse had the nerve to reject me for the 2nd time today 😤

Yes, I think it’s unlikely that schools dip into the R pile but I do think any schools that haven’t sent Rs yet are still up in the air, which is why I don’t believe in soft Rs

Thanks, I’m poetry. I checked portal before posting and nothing. Idrc enough to contact them but it’s weird they haven’t sent anything. Are you sure rejections went out? It’s largely irrelevant to me now but think it’s possible they are holding back in case they have more openings than expected.

Just realized CU-Boulder is the only school I haven’t heard anything from…