I think I may have made a decision.
Here are my results from this application process:
CU Boulder - accepted - no funding
Vanderbilt - accepted - TA ($25k/year) + Fellowship ($5k/year)
Lehigh - accepted - Fellowship ($25k/year)
GA Tech - accepted - I'm assuming no funding because I haven't heard anything
Princeton - rejected
Rutgers - ???!?! I'm sure I'll be accepted but I doubt they have any money
I was torn between Boulder and Lehigh. Boulder e-mailed me yesterday and told me that I would not be receiving ANY funding, so that's definitely out of the running. It was my dream school and I feel like I was sort of led on, but I guess their financial situation is just not good right now (the economy, state school, etc.). I'm 95% sure I'm going to Lehigh. I feel like they actually want me to attend--multiple e-mails from several department heads, notifying me in early Feb, and a great research fit. Vanderbilt offered me a banging funding package but the research there isn't that strong (mostly computer modeling/simulation and little experimental work). Additionally, I went to undergrad there, so the question of being "inbred" comes into play. I'd rather have another University on my resume, to be honest. Lehigh has everything I want (minus maybe the location). The town kinda sucks, but it's way better than the sleepy, southern town where I currently reside. However, it is only an hour away from my parents' home and having lived over a 1000 miles away from my hometown for over 6 years, it would be nice to be close to family.
Am I making the right decision?