Etale I'm shocked you didn't get it last year with those scores, but I had the same problem
Last year: E/E VG/VG G/E
This year: VG/VG E/G
Last year my broader impacts received good reviews and the only criticisms my application received were with regard to Intellectual Merit. So I rewrote my proposal but stuck with the same structure on broader impacts (but updated it obviously). I receive praise from both reviewers on my intellectual merit, but got slammed on broader impacts. What!? I heeded the advice I received last year, and some how, I managed to get worse scores. I don't get it...
