I don't know of anyone at ND for PhD from SLU--most students come from ND's MTS, Duke, Yale, Harvard, or BC/Weston (or from the UK). I would shoot high in applying to those programs (if its not too late). I got into ND's MTS from a rather no-name college and no coursework in theology, so its possible (and not that rare here, either). Anyway, it seems easier to make the transition to a brand-name school at the Master's level rather than for the PhD -- Last year only half of the people applying from ND got into first or second-tier schools, so even then it is a crapshoot. Anyhow, my point is that it is really ridiculously hard to get into the best PhD programs, and I've seen people coming from ND with incredible recommendations, publications/conferences, and 1500 GREs and not get in to top schools, so I would be wary in accepting anything but the best possible master's program you can get into. Find out where students at each Master's program get accepted before you apply.