As a current GW student I can offer a few more pro's:
-GREAT and very organized career services. The director is comfortable advising both domestic and international students, and is familiar with both public and private sectors along with suitable MPP/MPA placements in each. From my experience that's very rare for an MPP/MPA program! He's also great for resume and cover letter reviews, and helps you tailor each one to individual agencies and organizations.
-On top of that, there are CONSTANT site visits to federal agencies. GAO, OMB, CBO, BEA, etc... you get to go there, network over lunch with the HR people and alumni, and they give you a presentation. It definitely helps to get your name out there, and you actually get to see the agency. I think we've also had site visits to a nonprofit or two and consulting firms as well. Professors spend time advising these agencies so they also have a world of connections within them (one professor, Dr. Newcomer is constantly giving presentations to GAO, world bank, united way, etc on program evaluations)
-VERY applied work. This actually does come quite handy if you want a job/internship... In program evaluation students do a REAL program evaluation for clients. It's not some extra "consulting" class you have to beg to get enrolled in (like at Georgetown or other programs), its just a class with this as a component of it. You work on a team of two for a local non-profit or government agency. The work you produce is real, solid, very in depth, and gives you an incredible experience (trust me--It's a major selling point for jobs and internships!). Statistics courses also include very applied work (along with the theoretical of course), as well as economics, public budgeting, etc.
-Location: DC right now is key as the market contracts. Paid internships are becoming less common around the country. Being in DC, especially during the school year allows you to find not only a great internship, but a paid one year round. Often organizations will just keep their spring intern on for the summer, which really helps you out when you need a summer internship (federal agencies do this quite often...). I have yet to hear from a fellow student who wanted a good, paid internship and couldn't find one.
-Alumni network: since most stay in town you have a HUGE and very very very friendly one!
-Cost: GW is actually about $5,000 cheaper per semester than Georgetown (not sure the other comparisons, sorry!). And also GW will let you move between full time and part time status very easily if your internship turns into a full time job (or if you decide to stop working full time and take more courses).
Cons:
-If you stay in DC the name brand value of Georgetown, UMaryland, GW and American are all the same. GTown students do not get better jobs or internships than anyone else in my experience (I have a number of friends there). Salary figures all look the exact same too...
BUT if you plan on moving away from DC this could be an issue. GW is well known nation wide, but Gtwon does have a more internationally recognized name.
- I have heard that the lower level of theoretical work is bad for PHD hopefuls... but I have a friend who went from GWU to a top 3 social science PHD, and I know a number of others who have also moved on to PHD's... So although I can't guarantee it is not an issue, I'm pretty sure it's not. Ask the google group to be sure, Paul or Catherine should know for sure if you are really concerned about this.
-Not as quant heavy as ford school or Harris. If you want a highly quant job (like statistician or economist) this is likely not the place for you. You have plenty of econ and stats, but less of a hardcore calculus focus (granted though--in 99% of policy jobs you wont need it, but perhaps its a good selling point? Can't say as I've never tried it, the Harris student might know better)
Everyone should calm down about their letters too--I got mine 3 weeks after my official decision. I also know it is possible to get funding from alternate standing as at least a few people I know have said they got it. You just have to wait until after April 15th to know for sure.
Feel free to PM me with any questions! I'll be honest, I promise.